I sort of OD'ed watching the long form TV programs tonight on Hurricane Katrina. It's just so awful, but I can't look away. I never could. It feels strange not to be working the story in the newsroom, I've been there for so many of the big ones.
Jeanne Meserve's reporting really struck me the other day, she had just become so emotionally involved, it was wrenching. And her observations here below are the ones that hit me the hardest as well. I always worry about her in those hurricanes, she's so tiny, she looks like she'd just blow away in the wind. When she was out in St Augustine in one of the big storms last year, I was wishing they'd just tie her down or something.
Link: CNN.com - CNN: Heartbreak and destruction in small towns and large - Aug 31, 2005.
New Orleans destruction recalls past tragedies
Posted: 4:12 p.m. ET
CNN's Jeanne Meserve in Baton Rouge, Louisiana recounting her time spent amid the destruction in New Orleans
On the way out of New Orleans, it looked like the dust bowl. You've seen the pictures of the dust bowl, of people piled onto the backs of tracks and moving their lives. That's what is happening here. It's extraordinary to witness.
I truly believe that apart from 9/11 this is one of the most significant events that has ever hit this country. Anybody who tells you this disaster is going to be rectified in a matter of months hasn't seen the situation.
People are carrying their children, trying to get them to safety. A woman coming down to the police, close to hysterics, saying, "My elderly mother is in a building over there, she needs dialysis. She can't get it. She is dying. Can you help me?"
And the police had to say, "There is absolutely nothing we can do. We don't have a precinct house. We don't have communication. There is absolutely nothing we can do for you."
That was amazing to me.
The other thing that struck me was the looting. The police were standing in the middle of the street and right in front of them stores were being ransacked. And they didn't even make an effort to stop it. I don't think they could, under the circumstances.
They were totally outnumbered. They couldn't call for any reinforcements. And frankly, the priority now isn't property. The priority has to be people and people's lives. The police are there protectively, I think, in case things escalate even further. But they are powerless. They're powerless in this situation.
We did see tree removal trucks, electric trucks. So help is beginning to come in.
[...]
So the tree removal trucks couldn't get a person who needed dialysis closer to medical help? I suppose, if they were clearing pathways to get emergency workers through, but if they were just clearing trees while PEOPLE were still in danger, I'd have real issues with that. I'd also have an issue with all those journalists standing around filing stories while people were calling out for help, but I know from Meserve's reporting that she went far beyond any such thing, helping people to the point that she was just emotionally wrung out. She just impresses the hell out of me.
New Orleans a refugee city
Posted: 3:46 p.m. ET
CNN's Jim Spellman in New Orleans, Louisiana
New Orleans has fast become a refugee city. Thousands and thousands of people are seeking shelter on the highway overpasses looking for some sort of help, some sort of information.
They are screaming out to us and anybody around for water and for help. They are looking for information and for a way to get out.
On the highway overpasses and underneath the highways as well, people are trying to find a spot for themselves.
[...]
This struck me on the television programs tonight too, all those people screaming for help. It has to be distressing. But arguing with the TV, as I like to do, I also found myself wondering if the apocalyptic landscape wouldn't have triggered more of a self preservation instinct in some people, as I imagine (here from my safe and comfortable distance) it would with me.
If I became homeless overnight in that landscape, I think those shopping carts are the way to go. But I can't imagine NOT leaving my house/rubble with whatever I could grab, extra shoes, a jacket, something to catch water when it rains. People were screaming for water, and then later the reporter observed that it had rained that kind of hot hard rain New Orleans often gets.
Rather than sitting and demanding help, why aren't more people making makeshift camps, water catchers, little shelters of scrounged stuff instead of acting like nothing could happen until help arrived? One woman admitted she was in a hurry to get out of her house, but didn't even think to take anything with her. The day late rising water would have afforded some opportunity to prepare to live as humans did before technology took care of so many of our needs.
Another woman on one of the programs tonight stood and demanded a FEMA trailer right now, complaining that she had to sleep on her brother's front porch.
Of course the need is great, but is her brother begrudging her houseroom, making her sleep on the porch? Immigrants to the US often think nothing of surviving with too many family members in a small space, and this was certainly a matter of survival. I supposed the brother's house could have been structurally damaged, so no one was sleeping inside, but it would have probably been cooler sleeping on the porch anyway.
I was just struck, in an unkind moment no doubt, by how ill-equipped so many of us are to live as people did even during the Depression, we are so dependent on technology. Even the reporters continually referred to not having electricity as "primitive." Yet for many in the rural U.S., there was no electricity for much of the past century, and Victorians had no electricity as well. I'm sure those people would bristle at the idea that they were being called "primitives."
New Orleans airport becomes makeshift hospital
Posted: 2:20 p.m. ET
CNN's Ed Lavandera in Kenner, Louisiana
I just spoke with one of the officials here who is in charge of organizing the entire logistical situation at the Louis Armstrong International Airport here in New Orleans. This is where over the last 12 hours a team of FEMA workers have been setting up a field hospital, one of about 40 or so that have been set up across the region.
To give you a sense of just how massive this operation is, consider that in the four major hurricanes that hit Florida last year there were never more than five of these field hospitals set up at any time.
[...]
That is about the most mind-boggling thing I've heard so far. Wow.
Louisiana Senator Mary Landrieu's plea on TV to hotels to open up as Red Cross refugee housing was also telling. If that doesn't happen, people will run out of money and end up wandering the streets. Massive refugee camps would have to be set up, while the hotel rooms stood empty, waiting for paying customers. There's this massive outpouring of charity, but it will remain to be seen if real charity opens up somewhere where it could make the most difference, at the hotels and motels so many people have evacuated to.
New Orleans will be a ghost town, they're saying through December. An empty place with a broken down infrastructure. My god, that will be something like out of a freaky apocalypse movie.
New Orleans getting worse by the hour
Posted: 1:03 p.m. ET
CNN's John Zarella in New Orleans, Louisiana
[...]
In New Orleans, there's no sanitation any longer. The knee-deep water in the hotel lobby is just full of stench. It is a miserable, deteriorating situation in the city and it is growing worse by the hour and the water is rising.
The fact of the matter is this bowl, as they call it, is filling up. The estimates of time that it's going to take to get the water out of the bowl are three to six months. You could be sitting there in absolutely untenable conditions, in water that is filled with disease and germs, for months to come, walking through it, slogging through it.
With the looting that's going on and with the deteriorating sanitation conditions, it is a situation where you can't cover the story because you can't venture out from the hotel. It's so dangerous, one, because the water is getting higher, and two, because of the disease factor that is beginning. There's no food, there's no water.
I'm hearing they fear cholera. Hell, that even FEELS Victorian.
One man on TV righteously screamed about how long it took officials to come out and cover up his dead neighbor, out in the middle of the street, two days. I hollered right back at the TV on that one... WHY DIDN'T YOU GO OUT THERE AND COVER UP YOUR NEIGHBOR?! Sheesh. You needed an "official" to cover up the body of someone you knew?
Maybe we are MORE primitive, with our electricity, technology, and infrastructure dependencies.
Shreveport hospital in dire need
Posted: 12:36 p.m. ET
CNN's Deborah Feyerick in Shreveport, Louisiana
We had a conversation with one family who had left New Orleans. They are desperately trying to get in touch with their sister. She is a college nurse at the Memorial Medical Hospital on Napoleon Street. The story they told us of what is going on at that hospital is quite dramatic.
According to their sister, looters are trying to get into the hospital. There's no electricity. The nurses, the doctors and their families have virtually locked themselves into the medical center and they don't know when they are going to be able to get out.
The story they were telling us is that the hospital administration was telling the staff there it would be five days until they might be able to be rescued. They are telling us that people in the hospital are dying because there's no electricity.
One nurse walked outside to get a breath of fresh air. She was robbed at gunpoint. There were National Guard that was around the hospital, but apparently we are told they pulled out in order to help with the prisoner uprising that happened yesterday.
[...]
That is a horrific thing, and I'm hearing other similar stories. Hospitals under attack by armed gangs, folks inside fearing for their lives.
Hannah Arendt I think it was wrote about Mexico City after the devastating earthquake, about the spontaneous appearance of an organically democratized civil society, of people helping each other and pulling together in the complete absence of any kind of official help or relief. Maybe those observations were anomalous and not generalizable to the larger human condition.
Homes flattened in Biloxi
Posted: 12:15 p.m. ET
CNN's Ted Rowlands in Biloxi, Mississippi
Many structures along the Mississippi coast have been literally flattened by Hurricane Katrina.
It is difficult for search and rescue crews to wade through this. This is expanded over miles and miles, including some larger cities like Biloxi and smaller cities and townships.
Vast stretches have been flattened by Hurricane Katrina. The death toll continues to rise here. People have been trickling in against the advice of authorities to see if their homes withstood the hurricane.
[...]
This is one foreboding thought I had the day the hurricane came ashore and initial reports were far too innocuous. I thought, "No, this can't be true." I had the same feeling at work that Sunday of the Asian tsunami, knowing as an Alaskan that with a quake that big, there had to be a lot more we weren't yet aware of.
What I went through my mind with Katrina was, "Oh no, someplace is going to get 'Homesteaded.'" I wish I'd been wrong, but seeing the images of Gulfport, even though it is far worse than Andrew, I'm struck by the resemblance to the matchsticks Homestead, Florida was reduced to.
This was it, though. The one they've been predicting for many years, people who study the recent overdevelopment of coastal areas. At least one TV report did touch on that, the link from the severity of the devastation to the destruction of the marshes that provided something of a buffer zone for the worst of the storms.
The one thing that didn't happen that those doomsayers had warned of, the bullet we did dodge, related to the lack of adequate evacuation routes for the overpopulated newly developed coastal areas. The nightmare feared was that cars could have been backed up in a massive traffic jam for miles on the evacuation routes even as the storm was actually hitting, and the people in them would be swept away as well, like so many segments of those Gulf coastal bridges.
Recent Comments